Riots and Wages in Singapore: Part 3

By Roy Ngerng and Leong Sze Hian

In the last article, we wrote about the huge wage disparity in Singapore between the best paid politicians in the world among the PAP politicians and how Singaporeans and the workers in Singapore are paid the lowest wages among the high-income countries.

In this article, we will continue to illustrate to you how wide the wage gap in Singapore really is.

  • Singapore has the largest wage disparity among workers of different educational levels among all the high-income countries.
  • The wages of workers with polytechnic diploma or lower would remain stagnant or drop over time, as they age.
  • The poorest 20% in Singapore have only 5% of the share of all income while the richest 20% have 49% of the share of all income (in 1998) – the largest disparity among the high-income countries.

(A) Singapore has the largest wage disparity among workers of different educational levels among all the high-income countries

Do you know that when compared to the other high-income countries, the wage difference between a university degree graduate and someone who has a below upper secondary education is the highest in Singapore (Chart 1). Whereas a university degree graduate in Singapore would earn 3.7 times higher than some with a below upper secondary school education, this would be only 1.3 times in Italy.

Slide3

Chart 1: OECD Indicators Education at a Glance 2013

Thus there is huge pay disparity between Singaporeans of different educational qualifications, which is concerning because such an indefinite policy measure would only result in entrenched divisions among the people in Singapore and create artificial social divisions.

(B) The wages of workers with polytechnic diploma or lower would remain stagnant or drop over time, as they age

However, the policy discrimination isn’t only reflected in educational discrimination, but in age discrimination as well.

Over the lifetime of a Singaporean who has a polytechnic diploma, they can expect their pay to remain unchanged or even decrease (Chart 2).

Slide1

Chart 2: Report on Wages in Singapore, 2011

The scenario for someone without a polytechnic diploma is even bleaker – their pay will indefinitely decline as they grow older (Chart 3).

Slide2

Chart 3: Report on Wages in Singapore, 2011

Thus, if only 30% of Singaporeans are able to enter local public universities, for the rest of the 70% of Singaporeans who earn $2,000 or less, they would only be able to earn barely the minimum needed to scrape by in Singapore, and might never be able to retire.

And because only the pay of university degree graduates are likely to increase over time, the wage disparity over time thus widens further (Chart 4). A university degree graduate in Singapore would earn 6.2 times higher than someone with a below upper secondary school education, whereas this is only 1.6 times in Denmark.

Slide6

 Chart 4: OECD Indicators Education at a Glance 2013

(C) The poorest 20% in Singapore have only 5% of the share of all income while the richest 20% have 49% of the share of all income (in 1998)

The next set of statistics will shock you. 

Thus because there is such huge wage differences in Singapore, for the poorest 20% of Singaporeans, they are only able to have 5% of the share of all income (Chart 5), which is the lowest among the high-income countries – the poor in Singapore are worst off.

Slide3

Chart 5: The World Bank World Development Indicators: Distribution of income or consumption

In contrast, the richest 20% would take in a 49% share of all wealth in Singapore – nearly half of all the income, and this is the highest when compared with the other high-income countries (Chart 6).

Slide4

Chart 6: The World Bank World Development Indicators: Distribution of income or consumption

Not only that, the second 20% poorest have only a 9% share of all income – the lowest among all the high-income countries as well, and the third 20% in the middle-income group have only a 15% share of all income – also the lowest!

In short, the poorest 60% in Singapore have only 29% of the wealth – the lowest of all the high-income countries (Chart 7)! Can you imagine that – 60% of the population in Singapore and they don’t even have one-third of the total income in Singapore!

Slide5

Chart 7: The World Bank World Development Indicators: Distribution of income or consumption

The comparison from Charts 5 to 7 for Singapore’s statistic is from 1998, the last year where this data is publicly available.

However, since then, the income inequality in Singapore has risen dramatically – we are now the country among the high-income countries with the highest income inequality (Chart 8), and one of the highest in the world.

Slide6

Chart 8: OECD StatExtract Income Distribution and PovertyKey Household Income Trends, 2012

As such, in all likelihood, the poorest 20% would most likely have less than 5% of income while the richest 20% would most likely accumulate more than half of all the wealth by now.

Not surprising since we have the largest wage disparity among the high-income countries.

So, what does the Singapore prime minister actually mean when he said that, “if you are poor in Singapore, there’s no fun. But I think you are less badly off than if you were poor nearly anywhere else in the world,” or that, “poor people are not poor by any international standard“.

Quite contrary to what the Singapore prime minister had said, the poor in Singapore are much worse off than the poor in other high-income countries, and are poor by any international standards! The statistics fly in the face of what the prime minister had said! Is this complete bullocks?

But really, how did Singapore come to a stage where there is such a massive wage gap, and how did our people become the poorest among the high-income countries, even as much as Singapore is one of the richest countries in the world, by GDP per capita. Why does Singapore now have the 4th highest concentration of billionaires in the world, but also have the highest poverty rate among all the high-income countries, and even countries in the region?

How does the PAP government intend for Singaporeans to live adequately if they continue to pursue policies which depress the wages of Singaporeans and the workers in Singapore, whilst contributing the lowest returns to Singaporeans’ CPF, while forking out the least for the health spending for Singaporeans? How can the government continue to expect Singaporeans to pay for the second most expensive public universities in the world, while Singaporeans receive the lowest proportion of scholarships, while also accumulating debt at a very young age even before we start work, and where whence we start, are faced with one of the world’s highest cost of living and highest prices in the world, on marginal wages?

The PAP’s Policies Will Lead to the Downfall of Singapore

What’s more, where policies have created such distinct educational pathways where Singaporeans seemingly end up in fixed career paths in life, the wage divide that follows us for the rest of our lives, serves only to entrench the unevenness and inequality further. Coupled with stagnant and declining wages as one grows older and an estimated 28% of Singaporeans living in poverty, the plight of Singaporeans is in indeed in danger.

Minister for Law and Foreign Affairs K Shanmugam might ask, “what evidence is there … (to suggest) that these workers were deeply disaffected and that is why the riot took place.” He had also said that, “I’m not saying you can’t say it, but I would like to see some evidence to back up a fairly substantive statement like that. All I can see is assertions and the fact that you repeat the assertions doesn’t make it a fact.”

As it stands, Singaporeans and workers in Singapore are paid the lowest wages in the world and the poverty rate is the highest among the high-income countries and possibly the highest among countries even in the region. Thus it also does not help when we have ministers such as Minister for Social and Family Development Chan Chun Sing, who had said that it is not helpful to define a poverty line in Singapore because, “if we use a single poverty line to assess the family, we also risk a ‘cliff effect’, where those below the poverty line receive all forms of assistance, while other genuinely needy citizens outside the poverty line are excluded.

And on top of all of the above, the lives of lower-income Singaporeans may be further compromised by the Government, from a cashflow perspective – not spending a single cent on healthcare, CPF and HDB.

If it is not already apparent to the PAP government, the episodes and revelations over the past one year – the strike and riot, and calls to implement a minimum wage and to define a poverty line – are signs of the burgeoning needs of a populace who are already on the brink of social meltdown and if the PAP continues to ignore the screaming needs of the populace, such ignorance and strident denial will only serve to mark the end of the PAP’s demise in no uncertain terms.

Perhaps such is the evolution of power and societal change where time and again, history has shown, that if power is allowed to consume the will of individuals, that the only path to be ridden is one of downfall and then renewal, and Singapore does not seem to be immuned to the fate that has befallen all other political regimes and societies. A much needed breath of fresh air for the people of Singapore, it would seem, but only when the rot of power corrupted is overcome.

*****

Empowering Singaporeans had just organised our first workshop – Towards a Better Education System – last week. We will be holding the next workshop to discuss about the jobs, wages and employment situation in early 2014. 

Follow us on the Empowering Singaporeans Facebook page or email us at empoweringsingaporeans@gmail.com for more updates.

Towards Better Jobs, Wages & Employment in Singapore Teaser Poster

19 comments

  1. eric

    Hi Roy. You really tau nau Pai. What will happen if a server in a fast food joint with sec 3 education earn $3000 and a grad from nus earn $3500? You mai xiao.

  2. eric

    Hi Roy.

    How.come you.don’t want to answer my question? You say bus drivers should earn as much as the nordic counterparts, but how much is bus fare in nordic countries?
    You love to paint pap will bring downfall, but I think you thin. Too much until tau nau Pai. If pap is so bad, than most countries in the world liao. Here got low unemployment, almost no homeless, someone only in Singapore can you expect a newly married young couple buy their own flat. What else you want huh? You tak chey too much. Gong jiao way.

  3. eric

    Hi Roy!

    Remember the occupy movement? Your ‘stats’ makes sg better than many countries.leh. Please answer me leh;

    1- how much bus fare in nordic countries.
    2- are you a how loan elitist who refuses to answer people? You gong jiao way, u say pap no good, you also same same lah, also don’. Want to talk to your public.or you only speak to kiang lang and not normal singaporeans?

  4. eric

    Hi Roy.

    Really ah meh? Roy oh Roy. You kiang lang right? You can ez wiki and find out lah. You making uneducated people like me confuse lah! In Singapore, unlimited bus rides is $198 meh? For nordic.countries only $90 for Everyone meh? Sure or not huh? What i understand is different u know. U can.always find out from.the net, but you so kiang u shd know.mah.

    You kiang lang.but cannot anyhow bluf you know? Must be a good boy and tell the truth. If you do, I give you a sweet Ok?

  5. eric

    Hi Roy! Take a poll lah. See how much.people spend on Mrt/bus a month. Anywhere near $198? Got meh? You got spend that much.meh? Or you.drive? Looks like you don’t take public transport.

  6. eric

    Hi Roy! How are you today?

    Public buses in Lahti cost €53 for 30 days.not including trams or subway. Lahti is not Helsinki which cost more. So you are confusing your readers u know when u claim season pass in sg cost $198 for entire public transportation system in sg(which most of us don’t spent anywhere near $198) and nordic countries abt $90 and that for limited service.

    Should you and hui hui be more responsible in posting such ‘facts’.

    • eric

      Hi:)

      Why u say I fanny puppy leh? Why the name calling? Will Roy approve? Everyone should have the freedom to support who they like. So why you stood so low and start name calling leh?
      Maybe Roy did not have time to check some facts, what I post is to share info with Roy.

      So . Support pap or sdp or wp, it’s my.choice. Are you trying to take away people’s freedom to.choose? So if your favourite party wins the election, will you pressure your government to clamp down on pap supporters? Grow up lah.

  7. eric

    Why should I F.O? Don’t you want a country that is free for anyone to express their views? Yet you stood so low and act like the moral authority and ask me to F.O because you dislike something I wrote? You have a 3rd world mentality and suppressed freedom of discussion. ROY, would you want to take a stand about this guy’s oppression and bullying tactics? Unless you encourage such behaviour? If you stay silent on his bullying oppressive behaviour, everything you wrote about the pap contridicts yoursel as you gave him the support of bullying people who disagre. With him. Take action.

  8. youmakenosense

    this Roy guy is stupid. Spreading nonsense. Fyi i am not supporting any party, but i think you need to go to school.

  9. Be_A_Thai

    If inflation are factor in, our real pay is even lower.
    I had been hospitalized before and I know the medishield is of no help compared to Thailand’s Social Security which covers everything including outpatient and dental treatment; best of all – only 30 baht. Just flash your SS card, no upfront payment. Amid the political problems, the Thai government take good care of its citizen; I felt like a foreigner in my own country; that’s why I left.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s